NALP's Public Service Attorney Salary Survey Shows Pay Remains Lowest at Civil Legal Services Organizations

NALP Bulletin+, May 2024

NALP's latest analysis from the 2023 Public Service Attorney Salary Survey shows that civil legal services/legal aid organizations continue to pay lower salaries as compared to other public service employers, such as public defenders and other non-profits. This is consistent with trends from prior surveys dating back to 2004. Salary figures for the 2023 survey were reported as of October 1, 2023, for U.S. based public service employers.

The disparities in pay for lawyers working in civil legal services organizations begin post-graduation and grow as lawyers progress in their careers. For example, the median salary for entry-level civil legal services lawyers was $64,200 in 2023 — more than $5,000 below the median entry-level salaries for other public interest organizations ($69,500) and public defenders ($69,600). For civil legal services lawyers with five years of experience, the gap widens to more than $7,000 and $16,000, respectively, as compared to these other public service employers. The pay differential expands further at the 11-15 years of experience mark, where the median salary for those working in civil legal services is $86,000, which is more than $20,000 below their public service peers. NALP did not receive enough responses from district attorney/local prosecuting offices in 2023 to provide nationally representative analyses and comparisons for this employer type. (See Table 1.)

The 2023 survey also collected new information about financial compensation for legal interns. The majority of all public service organizations reported that they had paid interns, but they were most prevalent in public defender offices, where approximately two-thirds of offices compensated their interns. (See Table 2.)

When making trend comparisons using the survey data, it is important to note that NALP received a smaller number of responses (129) to the 2023 survey as compared to previous years and because of this lower response, the data may not be as nationally representative as compared to prior surveys when respondent pools were larger, particularly from 2004-2018. Similar to the 2022 survey, this year's dataset skewed more heavily toward organizations in larger-sized population areas — with 55% of responses submitted from employers located in metropolitan population areas of over four million people — locations that tend to have higher salaries. Surveys prior to 2022 had a better balance between employers located in rural/small population areas vs. large metro population areas.

Despite the limitations of the respondent pool, the rate of growth in median salaries since the 2022 survey (reported as of January 1, 2022) was larger than the typical rate observed across most prior years. This is not necessarily surprising, as the United States was still recovering from 2022's 40-year inflation high. This recovery, in conjunction with continued rising salaries in private practice employment, as well as staffing shortages amongst some public service employers, may have contributed to larger than usual wage growth at public service organizations. For example, median entry-level salaries were $6,500 - $9,900 higher across the three different public service organization types as compared to the 2022 survey. However, the entry-level salary figures from this survey were somewhat higher compared to the overall median salary of $62,000 for graduates going into public interest employment (reported as of March 15, 2023) from NALP's Class of 2022 Employment Report and Salary Survey, and for which we receive more comprehensive coverage of entry-level salaries — an indication that the higher share of respondents from larger metro populations areas to the Public Service Attorney Salary Survey may be slightly skewing these figures upward. Nevertheless, both NALP surveys show larger than average wage growth for public service lawyers. (See Table 3 and Chart 1.)

Finally, the results from the Public Service Attorney Salary Survey, taken in tandem with its law firm companion piece — NALP's 2023 Associate Salary Survey — highlight well-understood, but nonetheless sobering distinctions between public sector/public interest salaries and law firm salaries. For example, the median first-year associate salary at a law firm of 100 or fewer lawyers was $155,000 in 2023, more than double that of entry-level lawyers within public service organizations. The median first-year salary for firms with 101-250 lawyers was $160,000 and it was $215,000 in the largest firms of more than 1,000 lawyers. Further, these figures were collected prior to several publicly announced salary increases by large firms in the latter part of 2023 and early 2024 — with some entry-level salaries now starting at $225,000. These $225,000 starting salaries paid by many large firms are beyond what even the most experienced lawyers can reasonably expect to earn at a public service organization and are approximately double the size (or more) of the median salaries of public service lawyers with more than 15 years of experience at organizations included within the survey. Thus, despite rising salaries at public service organizations, these employers are struggling to keep pace with the rate of wage growth in the private sector.

For results from prior years, see the Public Sector Salaries page.



Table 1. Salaries for Lawyers Working in Public Service Organizations by Type of Organization and Years of Experience
(average U.S. dollars per year as of October 1, 2023)

Years of Experience Median Average Middle Range of Salaries
(25th and 75th percentiles)
# of Organizations
Reporting
Civil Legal Services
1 year or less $64,200 $64,143 $57,533-69,500 36
2 years 67,000 68,477 62,000-72,102 37
3 years 68,750 68,831 63,000-73,000 34
4 years 71,000 72,778 65,280-80,000 35
5 years 73,700 75,201 69,437-80,000 33
6 years 75,974 77,521 70,768-82,000 34
7 years 78,260 79,515 70,987-85,000 35
8-10 years 79,860 81,353 74,153-86,000 35
11-15 years 86,000 87,483 79,213-97,454 37
More than 15 years 92,000 93,790 82,500-102,102 33
Public Defenders
1 year or less $69,608 $69,197 $63,500-75,066 17
2 years 72,966 75,578 67,000-81,728 16
3 years 82,155 81,952 70,496-90,284 16
4 years 85,455 87,826 72,000-100,000 14
5 years 90,000 91,403 75,804-100,404 15
6 years 89,665 92,734 77,476-105,637 15
7 years 89,149 92,835 80,620-99,942 13
8-10 years 98,500 96,646 85,000-109,811 15
11-15 years 106,883 105,658 92,658-119,260 16
More than 15 years 111,779 115,108 104,509-127,463 14
Public Interest Organizations (all specialty areas combined)
1 year or less $69,499 $68,907 $60,000-76,200 35
2 years 76,704 75,471 63,000-85,000 27
3 years 79,082 78,686 70,802-84,500 32
4 years 82,824 85,366 75,722-91,500 25
5 years 81,000 87,161 77,766-94,500 33
6 years 87,500 90,612 80,000-97,500 29
7 years 92,046 97,538 84,670-100,750 28
8-10 years 98,124 102,294 84,000-111,533 31
11-15 years 107,085 110,802 91,183-121,000 33
More than 15 years 121,530 127,317 96,010-146,500 28

Source: NALP's 2023 Public Service Attorney Salary Survey

Note: All salaries are reported as of October 1, 2023. Public service employers reported average salaries within their organization for each years of experience range, as applicable. In many cases, employers did not have lawyers in each years of experience category. The “Middle Range of Salaries” reports the range of salaries from the 25th to the 75th percentile. Half of all organizational salaries fell within this range. There were not enough responses from district attorney/local prosecuting offices in 2023 to provide nationally representative analyses for this employer type.


Table 2. Prevalence of Financial Compensation for Legal Interns in 2023 by Type of Public Service Organization

  Does your organization financially compensate any of its legal interns?
Type of Public Service Organization % Yes % No % Not Applicable/
Had No Legal Interns
in 2023
# of Organizations
Reporting
Civil Legal Services 51.2% 43.9% 4.9% 41
Public Defenders 66.7 33.3 0.0 18
Public Interest Organizations (all specialty areas combined) 56.6 30.2 13.2 53

Source: NALP's 2023 Public Service Attorney Salary Survey

Note: Data on the prevalence of financial compensation of legal interns is reported as of October 1, 2023. Some employers responding "yes" may compensate some, but not, all legal interns. There were not enough responses from district attorney/local prosecuting offices in 2023 to provide nationally representative analyses for this employer type.


Table 3. Median Salaries for Public Service Attorneys by Type of Organization and Years of Experience, 2004-2023

Years of Experience 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2018 2022 2023
Civil Legal Services
Entry-level $34,000 $36,000 $40,000 $42,000 $42,800 $44,600 $48,000 $57,500 $64,200
5 years 40,000 43,300 48,000 49,400 50,200 51,000 54,800 67,100 73,700
11-15 years 51,900 55,000 60,000 62,500 64,900 65,000 69,400 78,500 86,000
Public Defenders
Entry-level 39,000 43,300 47,400 47,500 50,500 50,400 58,300 59,700 69,600
5 years 50,000 54,700 60,000 60,300 62,800 63,000 68,000 75,700 90,000
11-15 years 65,000 65,500 75,000 76,200 78,600 84,500 96,400 100,500 106,900
Public Interest Organizations
Entry-level 36,700 40,000 41,000 45,000 45,000 46,000 50,300 63,000 69,500
5 years 46,300 52,000 53,800 53,600 56,300 59,000 65,000 78,700 81,000
11-15 years 64,000 65,000 69,200 70,900 75,000 75,000 80,500 95,000 107,100
 
Total Number of Responses 415 430 658 572 423 362 347 197 129

Source: NALP's Public Service Attorney Salary Survey, 2004-2023

Note: All figures have been rounded to the nearest $100. Salaries from 2004-2022 were reported as of January 1 of the reporting year; salaries for 2023 were reported as of October 1, 2023.


Chart 1. Median Salaries for Public Service Attorneys by Type of Organization and Years of Experience, 2004-2023




Source: NALP's Public Service Attorney Salary Survey, 2004-2023

Note: All figures have been rounded to the nearest $100. Salaries from 2004-2022 were reported as of January 1 of the reporting year; salaries for 2023 were reported as of October 1, 2023.

National Association for Law Placement, Inc.® (NALP®), 1220 19th Street NW, Suite 510, Washington, DC 20036-2405, (202) 835-1001 [email protected], © Copyright 2024 NALP

STAY CONNECTED



View Full Site